Welcome to Wagon Wheel Bar & Grill
Wagon Wheel Bar & Grill is a charming local gem located at 776 S College Ave, Rensselaer, IN. Renowned for its friendly atmosphere and exceptional service, this inviting establishment serves up delicious burgers that are a standout feature. Patrons rave about the unique flavors, distinguishing them from typical fast-food fare, making each bite a delightful experience. The casual dive bar vibe is complemented by a clean environment, ensuring comfort for guests. Whether you're stopping in for a quick bite or enjoying a drink, the warmth of the staff and the quality of the food make Wagon Wheel a must-visit destination.
Wagon Wheel Bar & Grill: Reviews & Ratings
My wife and i thought this was a great little local spot with friendly people and great simple food. I Had 2 wagon masters and wife had a regular cheese burger. The burgers actually had there own flavors not full of salt and seasoning like a fast food type burger always is. The waitress was very polite and genuinely nice. I will be going back again and again. The price was very reasonable.
My husband and I stopped here for a couple drinks and a quick bite. This place was wonderful! It has a neighborhood dive bar feel for sure, but it was very clean and the staff was above and beyond friendly. One of the best burgers I have ever had...I can’t even wrap my head around it. The burger is so simple but they apparently season it with magic fairy dust. Well done y’all, well done
Stop by for a drink with wife while kids went on there fist date at the roller ring. Nice friendly bar clean.
Great burger. Wagon wheel master... amazing! Good pizza. Friendly comfortable atmosphere & bartender. Last minute stop for food & now will definitely stop in or carry out when we are in town.
Great food extremely friendly staff always enjoy having lunch there
Total hidden gem! Best nachos and martini I’ve ever had. They serve nacho toppings on the side so you can build your perfect bite, and the bartender didn’t hold back on the olive juice in my martini — finally, someone who gets me. Would recommend
We came here with our son for his first bar experience. The Wagon Master burgers were great, the atmosphere was chill, the drinks were spot on, and the bartender was amazing! 10/10 and we WILL be back!
nice little bar to grab a quick little sandwich while i was in town for work i would go back for a beer or two they don’t take card so either bring cash or their is an atm by the entrance
Location
-
776 S College Ave, Rensselaer, IN 47978, United States Hotline: +1 219-866-9942
Welcome to the Wagon Wheel Bar & Grill, a delightful gem nestled at 776 S College Ave, Rensselaer, IN. This local favorite is where hearty meals meet an inviting atmosphere, ideal for both casual diners and those seeking a relaxing drink after a long day. When you step into Wagon Wheel, you're greeted by friendly faces and a vibe that embodies the warmth of a community dive bar.
The menu at Wagon Wheel is straightforward, yet each dish tells a story of thoughtfully crafted flavors. Diner feedback consistently highlights the rich, authentic taste of their burgers, particularly the Wagon Master, which has captured the hearts—and appetites—of many. Customers rave about the quality; no overpowering salt, just pure burger goodness that feels refreshingly homemade. As one satisfied patron, darin clatterbuck, noted, these burgers carry their own unique flavors, making every bite a pleasant surprise.
For those in need of a quick snack or a leisurely meal, the Wagon Wheel Bar & Grill also offers a selection of pizzas that have garnered praise for their deliciousness. Amanda Mikuly shared her experience, labeling the atmosphere as friendly and comfortable, and raved about the amazing Wagon Wheel Master burger. It's this balance of atmosphere and food that keeps customers returning time and again.
Customer service is another highlight of the Wagon Wheel experience. Reviews emphasize how the staff go above and beyond, making you feel welcome from the moment you walk through the door. Whether it's a drink with friends or a family meal, you can expect a warm greeting and attentive service that makes dining here even more enjoyable. Gina Petty captured this essence beautifully as she described her encounter, stating it was not only clean but also had staff that were genuinely friendly.
If you find yourself in Rensselaer, the Wagon Wheel Bar & Grill is a must-visit. With its cozy atmosphere, a menu that champions simplicity with remarkable flavors, and a staff dedicated to making your visit enjoyable, it's the perfect spot for a meal that feels both special and homely. Don't miss out on the opportunity to experience this inviting locale. Trust us, once you visit, you too will find yourself returning again and again.